HR 4783 - Claims Resolution Act of 2010

Mr. Speaker:  Titles 3 through 6 of the bill purport to settle four water rights claims against the United States by signing away the public’s right to nearly 300 BILLION gallons of water annually AND in perpetuity -- in addition to spending more than $1.2 billion.

          The proponents of the bill are correct that if taxpayers will end up paying more if the claims go to trial, then we should settle out of court.  But I sincerely doubt this is the case.

          For the better part of a year, I asked for a legal opinion from the Attorney General on this question -- to no avail -- until a day before the issue was first brought to the House floor. What we received was not a legal opinion assessing the validity of the claims or the extent of the taxpayers’ liability.  It was a general statement of their preference for settling claims rather than litigating them.

          And it is undermined by many specific objections raised by the Administration.  For example, with respect to the White Mountain Apache settlement, the Department of Interior wrote on November 15: “This authorizes federal appropriations for numerous tribal projects that are extraneous to settlement,” and urged “these projects should be considered on their own merits in separate authorizing legislation.”  Last year, it warned that funding would “be excessive if it were viewed as settlement consideration.”

          They also warned of language – still in the bill – which waives the sovereign immunity of the United States for future litigation.  They warned, “this provision will engender additional litigation – and likely in competing state and federal forums – rather than resolving the water rights disputes…”

“Extraneous to the settlement.” “Engender additional litigation.”  “Excessive if … viewed as settlement consideration.”   

Those aren’t my words – they’re this administration’s words.  In fact, the administration expressed so many reservations about aspects of these settlements that we can only conclude that these are not settlements negotiated by the Attorney General and presented to Congress, but rather a grab-bag written by Congress itself and now rubber-stamped by the Administration on political and not legal grounds.

We were initially told that the Attorney General never comments on the validity of claims, but we found this to be false.  For example, in the Colville case in 1994 involving a similar water rights settlement, when the Attorney General’s office believed we had a weak case and should settle, they warned us that we are “not that well postured for a victory on this claim” and that “the outcome could easily be a significant cost to the taxpayers and the public.”

That’s not what they’re saying in this case.

          Mr. Speaker, we have many more Indian Water settlements pending for vast quantities of water and substantial sums of money.  We need to get our act together on this.

I believe Congress needs to demand that the administration be candid and forthcoming in all claims for settlement, and that Congress insist that before it begins deliberating on a settlement, that the Attorney General has conducted and completed the negotiations, determined all the details, certified that the settlement is within the legal liability of the government and only then submits that settlement for consideration by Congress. 

          Anything less is breaching the fiduciary responsibility that we hold to the people of the United States. 

 

<

Tele-townhall banner 

Latest News

Statement in Response to the Proposal of the National Park Service to Increase Entrance Fees, Including those Charged to Visitors at Yosemite National Park:

Last year, Yosemite Park management sought to drastically reduce the park's amenities that attract visitors and generate revenues. This year, it seeks to increase admission fees on those same visitors by 50 percent.

Angels Camp Third Annual Gold Rush Day

The history of Angels Camp is the history of California and the history of westward expansion.

Remarks in Opposition to Authorizing the Arming and Training of FSA (Free Syrian Army)

All of us recognize the threat posed to our nation by the Islamic State. The question before us is whether to arm and train supposedly vetted elements of the Free Syrian Army as a proxy ground force.

View more »

Search

Connect with Tom

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • News Feed

Upcoming Events

Staff Satellite Office Hours

Office staff members are available to assist constituents with problems or concerns at satellite office locations held throughout the district.  Anyone wishing to discuss an issue of federal concern is invited to attend one of these satellite office sessions and speak with a member of staff.  For more information, or to reach staff, please call the district office at 916-786-5560.
  
Upcoming Staff Satellite Office Hours for October:
 
Amador County

Jackson
Tuesday, October 28th
9:30 am - 11:30 am
Conference Room D
County Administration Center
810 Court Street
 
Calaveras County
 
San Andreas
Tuesday, October 7th
9:30 am - 11:30 am
Calaveras County Water Agency Conference Room
120 Toma Court
 
El Dorado County
 
Camino
Thursday, October 9th
9:00 am - 11:00 am
Camino Pollock Pines
Chamber of Commerce
4123 Carson Road
 
El Dorado Hills
Thursday, October 9th
12:00 pm - 2:00 pm
El Dorado Hills Chamber of Commerce
2085 Vine Street, #105
 
South Lake Tahoe
Thursday, October 16th
9:00 am - 11:00 am
South Lake Tahoe Public Utility District
1275 Meadow Crest Drive
 
Fresno County
 
Auberry
Thursday, October 23rd
10:00 am - 12:00 pm
The Auberry Library
33049 Auberry Road
 
Madera County 
 
Oakhurst
Thursday, October 2nd
11:00 am - 1:00 pm
Yosemite Visitor Bureau Conference Room
40637 Highway 41
 
Coarsegold
Thursday, October 2nd
3:00 pm - 5:00 pm
Yosemite Lakes Park Clubhouse
30250 Yosemite Springs Parkway
 
Mariposa County 
 
Mariposa
Tuesday, October 21st
8:30 am - 10:00 am
Library Conference Room
4978 10th Street
 
Nevada County
 
Truckee
Thursday, October 30th
10:00 am - 11:30 am
Truckee Town Hall
Council Chambers
10183 Truckee Airport Road
 
Placer County
 
Auburn
Wednesday, October 15th
9am-11am
NEW LOCATION -
Auburn Chamber Of Commerce -
NEXT TO AUBURN VISITORS CENTER
Conference Room
1103 High Street
 
Lincoln
Wednesday, October 15th
3:00 pm - 5:00 pm
Lincoln City Hall
600 6th Street
 
Rocklin
Tuesday, October 28th
3:00 pm - 5:00 pm
Rocklin City Hall
3980 Rocklin Road
 
Tahoe City
Thursday, October 23rd
1:00 pm - 3:00 pm
NEW LOCATION - North Tahoe Arts Center
380 North Lake Boulevard
 
 
Tuolumne County
 
Sonora
Tuesday, October 7th
1:00 pm - 3:00 pm
Small Business Center Conference Room
99 N Washington Street
 
For further information on staff satellite office hours, please call 916-786-5560.